Hard upvote for taking time to describe the concept explicitly and conprehensibly, highlighting the possible places of confusion—non-physical aspect of qualia that is occasionally smuggled in the definition.
When you define qualia like you do, I (a Camp 1 person, as it turned out) am completely on board with you. Indeed I expect them to be explained with neuroscience, but that’s as you’ve noticed yourself—a bit of a different story.
Hard upvote for taking time to describe the concept explicitly and conprehensibly, highlighting the possible places of confusion—non-physical aspect of qualia that is occasionally smuggled in the definition.
When you define qualia like you do, I (a Camp 1 person, as it turned out) am completely on board with you. Indeed I expect them to be explained with neuroscience, but that’s as you’ve noticed yourself—a bit of a different story.