The traditional idea with genie is that they give you what you wanted but you missed the implications of what you wanted to have.
It’s garbage in, garbage out.
The problem isn’t vague instructions but vague goals.
Yeah...didn’t I just argue against that?* A genie with the goal of interpreting instruction perfectly and and the competence to interpret instructions corrrctly would interpret instruction s correctly.
or at least stipulate in the very first sentence.
The traditional idea with genie is that they give you what you wanted but you missed the implications of what you wanted to have.
It’s garbage in, garbage out.
The problem isn’t vague instructions but vague goals.
Yeah...didn’t I just argue against that?* A genie with the goal of interpreting instruction perfectly and and the competence to interpret instructions corrrctly would interpret instruction s correctly.
or at least stipulate in the very first sentence.