This isn’t what I’m saying, and indeed the thing you have laid out is not at all how it works. I’m saying that that thing is good, but I’m saying that the good thing doesn’t happen any less if you shut off one of the computers next to the other, that exact same thing still happens. It’s not that one instance devalues the other, it’s that they are the same object and removing one instantiation, under some conditions, doesn’t make your good experience any less real in any way that means anything.
If instead you’re talking about qualia happening in a different world than the one you’re in, then this is in fact even less what I’m saying and is obviously valuable from my perspective.
This isn’t what I’m saying, and indeed the thing you have laid out is not at all how it works. I’m saying that that thing is good, but I’m saying that the good thing doesn’t happen any less if you shut off one of the computers next to the other, that exact same thing still happens. It’s not that one instance devalues the other, it’s that they are the same object and removing one instantiation, under some conditions, doesn’t make your good experience any less real in any way that means anything.
If instead you’re talking about qualia happening in a different world than the one you’re in, then this is in fact even less what I’m saying and is obviously valuable from my perspective.