I’m planning to write up a summary of what I think this post’s points are, before trying to sort out whether I agree or what followup points seem relevant.
One thing that would be somewhat helpful is clarity over whether I should expect the post to have been optimized pedagogically, or whether it’s mostly just a chat transcript with mild cleanup and/or anonymization (I’m assuming the latter).
I’m not sure whether that’s actually relevant or not, but there’s a lot going on here and a little extra handle on the post’s frame felt potentially helpful.
It wasn’t an actual conversation between multiple people, this is just how it felt intuitive to try to explain the issue. When it’s an actual chat transcript I say so :)
I’m planning to write up a summary of what I think this post’s points are, before trying to sort out whether I agree or what followup points seem relevant.
One thing that would be somewhat helpful is clarity over whether I should expect the post to have been optimized pedagogically, or whether it’s mostly just a chat transcript with mild cleanup and/or anonymization (I’m assuming the latter).
I’m not sure whether that’s actually relevant or not, but there’s a lot going on here and a little extra handle on the post’s frame felt potentially helpful.
It wasn’t an actual conversation between multiple people, this is just how it felt intuitive to try to explain the issue. When it’s an actual chat transcript I say so :)