In that scenario lying may be better for both in the short term, but lying about being in love with someone to trick them into sleeping with you seems pretty likely to upset them more in the long term. And there are more gentle ways to put it which could make honestly explaining that it’s mostly a physical thing which would reduce the immediate negativity considerably, though the amount depends on the listener’s disposition.
I agree that it’s not necessarily unreasonable for a truth to be upsetting, but it is somewhat unreasonable to press someone for a truthful answer (especially something important), then be upset with them specifically for being honest, especially if they have indicated discomfort giving a direct answer and tried skirting around the subject (since this hints that it’s something which may be an uncomfortable truth they may want to avoid), even if it’s pretty common in many circles.
For the avoidance of doubt, in that situation I agree that one shouldn’t lie. I was commenting not on B’s behaviour and attitude but on A’s.
And, also for the avoidance of doubt, if Chris’s girlfriend was upset that he told her the truth rather than that he didn’t like her friends’ acting then she was being 100% unreasonable. (And, as I said, even if it was the latter, still pretty unreasonable. I was making a more general point.)
In that scenario lying may be better for both in the short term, but lying about being in love with someone to trick them into sleeping with you seems pretty likely to upset them more in the long term. And there are more gentle ways to put it which could make honestly explaining that it’s mostly a physical thing which would reduce the immediate negativity considerably, though the amount depends on the listener’s disposition.
I agree that it’s not necessarily unreasonable for a truth to be upsetting, but it is somewhat unreasonable to press someone for a truthful answer (especially something important), then be upset with them specifically for being honest, especially if they have indicated discomfort giving a direct answer and tried skirting around the subject (since this hints that it’s something which may be an uncomfortable truth they may want to avoid), even if it’s pretty common in many circles.
For the avoidance of doubt, in that situation I agree that one shouldn’t lie. I was commenting not on B’s behaviour and attitude but on A’s.
And, also for the avoidance of doubt, if Chris’s girlfriend was upset that he told her the truth rather than that he didn’t like her friends’ acting then she was being 100% unreasonable. (And, as I said, even if it was the latter, still pretty unreasonable. I was making a more general point.)