Cool, yes, I agree. But the reason other insiders don’t like that public criticism is because it reduces their status by association. Your colleagues paid to get a position in a status hierarchy which you are devaluing, and they make you internalize those costs.
Ok, yes that makes a lot more sense—whilst tarnishing by association increases incentives to point out flaws in your friend, it decreases incentives to point out flaws in your friend’s friend.
And since most of your friends are also your friends’ friends, the aggregate impact is to decrease incentives to point out flaws in your friends as well.
Cool, yes, I agree. But the reason other insiders don’t like that public criticism is because it reduces their status by association. Your colleagues paid to get a position in a status hierarchy which you are devaluing, and they make you internalize those costs.
Ok, yes that makes a lot more sense—whilst tarnishing by association increases incentives to point out flaws in your friend, it decreases incentives to point out flaws in your friend’s friend.
And since most of your friends are also your friends’ friends, the aggregate impact is to decrease incentives to point out flaws in your friends as well.