Eek. My first thought from Linch’s message was that it might be translation-induced but this convinces me that’s unlikely. Paging the gradual disempowerment crowd!
Interestingly I think this is slight evidence against gradual disempowerment concerns, which I would have thought would be worried that AI-written encyclicals would be more pro-AI. But of course it’s too early to tell.
GD is a fuzzy (and arguably unnatural) package but yeah I agree with both your responses to some extent. It looks like ‘unattributed, harmless (? for now) dependency, in a place you really specifically would want to reserve carefully for human reasoning if you were being conservative at all’. Smells disempowering to me.
Eek. My first thought from Linch’s message was that it might be translation-induced but this convinces me that’s unlikely. Paging the gradual disempowerment crowd!
Interestingly I think this is slight evidence against gradual disempowerment concerns, which I would have thought would be worried that AI-written encyclicals would be more pro-AI. But of course it’s too early to tell.
To me it seems like disempowerment because its people losing the ability/willingness to write their own analyses even where it’s embarrassing not to.
GD is a fuzzy (and arguably unnatural) package but yeah I agree with both your responses to some extent. It looks like ‘unattributed, harmless (? for now) dependency, in a place you really specifically would want to reserve carefully for human reasoning if you were being conservative at all’. Smells disempowering to me.