It’s similar to staying faithful to someone you love, e.g. a wife or a good king. Caring about the way the world really is even if the world is really painful. Not flinching away from reality because it tells you something you don’t want to hear, not rebuking reality because it dares to disagree with you, not resenting reality because it seems unjust. Not replacing reality with a fantasy because you’re bored or because you want to escape. Not gerrymandering the definition of what counts as staying faithful to reality. Like Eliezer’s “something to protect”. It’s something that binds you to reality and keeps you from going out and identifying with a lot of stupid hypotheses and having sex with tons of chicks and getting STDs or delusions or whatever. (Note that going on dates with a lot of ideas is great, but you shouldn’t have sex with every idea you come across.)
I really like this framework. In particular, the interpretation of Job that goes with it. I may want to use them as part of this year’s Less Wrong Solstice gathering, if that’s okay with you.
It’s similar to staying faithful to someone you love, e.g. a wife or a good king. Caring about the way the world really is even if the world is really painful. Not flinching away from reality because it tells you something you don’t want to hear, not rebuking reality because it dares to disagree with you, not resenting reality because it seems unjust. Not replacing reality with a fantasy because you’re bored or because you want to escape. Not gerrymandering the definition of what counts as staying faithful to reality. Like Eliezer’s “something to protect”. It’s something that binds you to reality and keeps you from going out and identifying with a lot of stupid hypotheses and having sex with tons of chicks and getting STDs or delusions or whatever. (Note that going on dates with a lot of ideas is great, but you shouldn’t have sex with every idea you come across.)
I really like this framework. In particular, the interpretation of Job that goes with it. I may want to use them as part of this year’s Less Wrong Solstice gathering, if that’s okay with you.
How did it go? It seems like it would create some unsettling ambiguity in the “happy” ending.
I did not end up using it, although I periodically stumble upon this again and still think it’s a neat way of thinking