I always wondered why, at the before-Christmas battle, Hermione didn’t give her wish to Sunshine to incentivize them to work together instead of defecting and turning traitor (that is to say- make the wish for sunshine and announce it before the battle.) It think it was the obvious course to unite the army, and it was the obvious Hermione thing to do. Did she fail to do this just because Dumbledore got to her first, or was this a true blind spot on her part?
I always wondered why, at the before-Christmas battle, Hermione didn’t give her wish to Sunshine to incentivize them to work together instead of defecting and turning traitor (that is to say- make the wish for sunshine and announce it before the battle.) It think it was the obvious course to unite the army, and it was the obvious Hermione thing to do. Did she fail to do this just because Dumbledore got to her first, or was this a true blind spot on her part?
Eliezer says: “There are always infinite policies to consider. I didn’t consider that one and neither did young Hermione.”
Ah- thank you. In retrospect what seems like “the obvious thing” to me is not always so.