Edit: By which I mean bogus’s comment, which does nothing beyond insulting lifelonglearner. Also, I’d guess quite a few commenters on this website are in the 95th percentile of (say) IQ at their school.
Strongly agree: bogus’s comment was stupid and well out of order. Yes, Dunning & Kruger found that some incompetent people think they’re good. That doesn’t mean that everyone who thinks they’re good is incompetent. I bet lifelonglearner is absolutely right about being in the top 5% in his school.
(Perhaps bogus is just saying “hahahaha, he said “top 5 percentile” where he should have said “95th percentile” but sorry, that too is stupid; lifelonglearner’s words were perfectly clear as they were.)
Ignore that comment. If you want, post whatever evidence you have of your ranking in your school, but don’t feel pressured to do so. Internally, to yourself, I’d recommend an outside view of this number—your ranking on various dimensions (intelligence, scholastic achievements, etc.) and what evidence you have to support or disconfirm those beliefs.
Top 5 percent is incredibly easy to believe on this site. But you should double-check often. You should also be aware that top few percent on one of these dimensions doesn’t make you particularly special by itself. There are roughly 15 million high-school students in the US alone, so 750,000 5-percenters.
That’s beautiful. We need a “Dunning–Kruger quote of the month” thread for this sort of stuff!
We need downvotes for this sort of stuff. ^
Edit: By which I mean bogus’s comment, which does nothing beyond insulting lifelonglearner. Also, I’d guess quite a few commenters on this website are in the 95th percentile of (say) IQ at their school.
Strongly agree: bogus’s comment was stupid and well out of order. Yes, Dunning & Kruger found that some incompetent people think they’re good. That doesn’t mean that everyone who thinks they’re good is incompetent. I bet lifelonglearner is absolutely right about being in the top 5% in his school.
(Perhaps bogus is just saying “hahahaha, he said “top 5 percentile” where he should have said “95th percentile” but sorry, that too is stupid; lifelonglearner’s words were perfectly clear as they were.)
Yikes! Edited the above comment to more properly reflect things.
Ignore that comment. If you want, post whatever evidence you have of your ranking in your school, but don’t feel pressured to do so. Internally, to yourself, I’d recommend an outside view of this number—your ranking on various dimensions (intelligence, scholastic achievements, etc.) and what evidence you have to support or disconfirm those beliefs.
Top 5 percent is incredibly easy to believe on this site. But you should double-check often. You should also be aware that top few percent on one of these dimensions doesn’t make you particularly special by itself. There are roughly 15 million high-school students in the US alone, so 750,000 5-percenters.
Seems good. I don’t really feel like add’l validation would be useful here, so I’m fine leaving the claim as-is.
Thanks for the general note about epistemic hygiene.