I do want to avoid gaslighting people. LessWrong and LessWrong 2.0 under my management has discouraged U.S. politics content for many years. We stopped around 4-5 years ago, as politics started being more relevant to many people’s goals on the site, though we still don’t allow it on the LW frontpage unless it tries pretty hard to keep things timeless and non-partisan.
Politics is the Mind-Killer: still applies; protects this forum from redditification and encourages us to avoid pointlessly alienating people/making enemies of each other.
US politics posting allowed/discouraged/banned: I’m not too fussed about where you set this dial. But if political discussion is going to happen here, I think it would be bad if you/we got pressured into bothsidesism (which could happen if PitMK is misrepresented as a prohibition on openly taking partisan-coded positions).
I do want to avoid gaslighting people. LessWrong and LessWrong 2.0 under my management has discouraged U.S. politics content for many years. We stopped around 4-5 years ago, as politics started being more relevant to many people’s goals on the site, though we still don’t allow it on the LW frontpage unless it tries pretty hard to keep things timeless and non-partisan.
Fair, but I see this as two distinct things:
Politics is the Mind-Killer: still applies; protects this forum from redditification and encourages us to avoid pointlessly alienating people/making enemies of each other.
US politics posting allowed/discouraged/banned: I’m not too fussed about where you set this dial. But if political discussion is going to happen here, I think it would be bad if you/we got pressured into bothsidesism (which could happen if PitMK is misrepresented as a prohibition on openly taking partisan-coded positions).