I like it, but not as much as I like two-axis proposals, which I think can be done with a smooth enough UI that they don’t impose a burden.
With something like the below, you can click to weak vote and hold to strong vote, just like we currently do, and can in one click express each of the four following positions:
I like/agree with this point, and furthermore think it’s being expressed correctly/is in line with norms of reasoning and discourse I want to see more of on LW (dark blue)
I like/agree with this point, but I want to note objection with how it’s being expressed/have reservations about whether it’s good rationality or good discourse (pale orange)
I dislike/disagree with this point, and want to note objection with how it’s being expressed (dark orange)
I dislike/disagree with this point, but want to endorse/support the way it was arrived at and expressed (pale blue)
I like it, but not as much as I like two-axis proposals, which I think can be done with a smooth enough UI that they don’t impose a burden.
With something like the below, you can click to weak vote and hold to strong vote, just like we currently do, and can in one click express each of the four following positions:
I like/agree with this point, and furthermore think it’s being expressed correctly/is in line with norms of reasoning and discourse I want to see more of on LW (dark blue)
I like/agree with this point, but I want to note objection with how it’s being expressed/have reservations about whether it’s good rationality or good discourse (pale orange)
I dislike/disagree with this point, and want to note objection with how it’s being expressed (dark orange)
I dislike/disagree with this point, but want to endorse/support the way it was arrived at and expressed (pale blue)
Oh yeah, I’ve seen you post this before, I liked it!