(More directly addressing the Duncan Sabien quote: I roughly agree with the quote in terms of the immediate value of doublecrux. This sequence of posts was born from 2 years of arguing with LessWrong team members who had _something_ like ‘good faith’ and even ‘understanding of doublecrux in particular’, who nonetheless managed to disagree for months/years on deep intractable issues. And yes I think there’s something directly valuable about the doublecrux framework, when you find yourself in that situation)
(More directly addressing the Duncan Sabien quote: I roughly agree with the quote in terms of the immediate value of doublecrux. This sequence of posts was born from 2 years of arguing with LessWrong team members who had _something_ like ‘good faith’ and even ‘understanding of doublecrux in particular’, who nonetheless managed to disagree for months/years on deep intractable issues. And yes I think there’s something directly valuable about the doublecrux framework, when you find yourself in that situation)