Totally fine to ask questions on old posts (they actually show up on the frontpage)
I think the point here was “it’s fine to describe things as emergent when that’s applicable – but it’s not an explanation that helps narrow down what’s going on. If it’s your only explanation, you can’t really distinguish between emergent things that work one way and ones that work another way. In the case of water, if you want to understand it (at the level that’d let you predict which other materials might have similar properties), you need to know something in addition to the fact that it’s “emergent.”
Totally fine to ask questions on old posts (they actually show up on the frontpage)
I think the point here was “it’s fine to describe things as emergent when that’s applicable – but it’s not an explanation that helps narrow down what’s going on. If it’s your only explanation, you can’t really distinguish between emergent things that work one way and ones that work another way. In the case of water, if you want to understand it (at the level that’d let you predict which other materials might have similar properties), you need to know something in addition to the fact that it’s “emergent.”