Perhaps, depends how it is. I think we could do worse than just have Anthropic have a 2 year lead etc. I don’t think they would need to prioritize profit as they would be so powerful anyway—the staff would be more interested in getting it right and wouldn’t have financial pressure. WBE is a bit difficult, there needs to be clear expectations, i.e. leave weaker people alone and make your own world https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o8QDYuNNGwmg29h2e/vision-of-a-positive-singularity There is no reason why super AI would need to exploit normies. Whatever we decide, we need some kind of clear expectations and values regarding what WBE are before they become common, Are they benevolent super-elders, AI gods banished to “just” the rest of the galaxy, the natural life progression of first world humans now?
I think the problem with WBE is that anyone who owns a computer and can decently hide it (or fly off in a spaceship with it) becomes able to own slaves, torture them and whatnot. So after that technology appears, we need some very strong oversight—it becomes almost mandatory to have a friendly AI watching over everything.
I’m considering a world transitioning to being run by WBE rather than AI so I would prefer not to give everyone “slap drones” https://theculture.fandom.com/wiki/Slap-drone To start with the compute will mean few WBE, much less than humans and they will police each other. Later on, I am too much of a moral realist to imagine that there would be mass senseless torturing. For a start if you well protect other em’s so you can only simulate yourself, you wouldn’t do it. I expect any boring job can be made non-conscious so their just isn’t the incentive to do that. At the late stage singularity if you will let humanity go their own way, there is fundamentally a tradeoff between letting “people”(WBE etc) make their own decisions and allowing the possibility of them doing bad things. You also have to be strongly suffering averse vs util - there would surely be >>> more “heavens” vs “hells” if you just let advanced beings do their own thing.
Perhaps, depends how it is. I think we could do worse than just have Anthropic have a 2 year lead etc. I don’t think they would need to prioritize profit as they would be so powerful anyway—the staff would be more interested in getting it right and wouldn’t have financial pressure. WBE is a bit difficult, there needs to be clear expectations, i.e. leave weaker people alone and make your own world
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/o8QDYuNNGwmg29h2e/vision-of-a-positive-singularity
There is no reason why super AI would need to exploit normies. Whatever we decide, we need some kind of clear expectations and values regarding what WBE are before they become common, Are they benevolent super-elders, AI gods banished to “just” the rest of the galaxy, the natural life progression of first world humans now?
I think the problem with WBE is that anyone who owns a computer and can decently hide it (or fly off in a spaceship with it) becomes able to own slaves, torture them and whatnot. So after that technology appears, we need some very strong oversight—it becomes almost mandatory to have a friendly AI watching over everything.
I’m considering a world transitioning to being run by WBE rather than AI so I would prefer not to give everyone “slap drones” https://theculture.fandom.com/wiki/Slap-drone To start with the compute will mean few WBE, much less than humans and they will police each other. Later on, I am too much of a moral realist to imagine that there would be mass senseless torturing. For a start if you well protect other em’s so you can only simulate yourself, you wouldn’t do it. I expect any boring job can be made non-conscious so their just isn’t the incentive to do that. At the late stage singularity if you will let humanity go their own way, there is fundamentally a tradeoff between letting “people”(WBE etc) make their own decisions and allowing the possibility of them doing bad things. You also have to be strongly suffering averse vs util - there would surely be >>> more “heavens” vs “hells” if you just let advanced beings do their own thing.