I agree that these are not the two worlds which would be helpful to consider, and your list of reasons are closer to my model than Lucie’s representation of my model.
(I do hope that my post somewhat decreases trust in Jack Clark and Dario Amodei and somewhat increases the incentives for the kind of governance that would not be dependent on trustworthy leadership to work.)
I agree that these are not the two worlds which would be helpful to consider, and your list of reasons are closer to my model than Lucie’s representation of my model.
(I do hope that my post somewhat decreases trust in Jack Clark and Dario Amodei and somewhat increases the incentives for the kind of governance that would not be dependent on trustworthy leadership to work.)