That doesn’t address the fact that Qiaochu has a different instinctive reaction.
The goal of this proposal is to deal with the fact that different people are different.
I completely understand the instinct.
I don’t think think Qiaochu would like the effect of posting Overton Window violating things on this website, not getting negative feedback here but actually suffering socially as a result.
It would be very nice if it would be possible to violate the Overton Window without having to think about it, but it isn’t as easy.