Wait—did someone actually show that Roko’s Basilisk is stupid and dumb? I believe that—it’s roughly a bad Pascal’s wager, but with a causal hook. But I think the reason discussion was banned was that it was causing severe discomfort, not that it was agreed to be harmless and meaningless.
In any case, your proposal does not have the causal hook that makes the Basilisk so tempting and unpleasant. It doesn’t blackmail you into creating the blackmailer.
Wait—did someone actually show that Roko’s Basilisk is stupid and dumb? I believe that—it’s roughly a bad Pascal’s wager, but with a causal hook. But I think the reason discussion was banned was that it was causing severe discomfort, not that it was agreed to be harmless and meaningless.
In any case, your proposal does not have the causal hook that makes the Basilisk so tempting and unpleasant. It doesn’t blackmail you into creating the blackmailer.