For me the solution by Fitch (the “logical school” mentioned in the Wikipedia article) is pretty conclusive. I wrote a post about it sometime ago, extending it to handle another variation of the paradox.
Yeah, that’s fair. I like my solution to the paradox over the logical school one since it focuses on the absurdity of a causal link between what the student expects and what occurs in reality as opposed to merely “surprising” being under-defined, but they’re both quite interesting.
For me the solution by Fitch (the “logical school” mentioned in the Wikipedia article) is pretty conclusive. I wrote a post about it sometime ago, extending it to handle another variation of the paradox.
Yeah, that’s fair. I like my solution to the paradox over the logical school one since it focuses on the absurdity of a causal link between what the student expects and what occurs in reality as opposed to merely “surprising” being under-defined, but they’re both quite interesting.