This is a decent start to a post. There should be more—perhaps your own answers to these questions (attempting to cover the field of possible answers) and a wrap-up conclusion. I’d be amazed if there wasn’t reasonably good philosophical work on the area already, for example.
It is a perfectly fine discussion post. I would agree with you for the main page.
Incidentally, since this is the discussion section, why don’t you provide some of what you think is missing? Find a few philosophical papers on the topic and link them?
Because I’m not a philosopher, don’t claim to be and don’t know the area :-) I said I’d be amazed if no-one had thought about this, but it’s possible they havent.
Yeah, it’s a good discussion post and appears to be generating discussion. I voted it up :-)
This is a decent start to a post. There should be more—perhaps your own answers to these questions (attempting to cover the field of possible answers) and a wrap-up conclusion. I’d be amazed if there wasn’t reasonably good philosophical work on the area already, for example.
(Yes, LessWrong posts do ask a lot.)
It is a perfectly fine discussion post. I would agree with you for the main page.
Incidentally, since this is the discussion section, why don’t you provide some of what you think is missing? Find a few philosophical papers on the topic and link them?
Because I’m not a philosopher, don’t claim to be and don’t know the area :-) I said I’d be amazed if no-one had thought about this, but it’s possible they havent.
Yeah, it’s a good discussion post and appears to be generating discussion. I voted it up :-)