“it’s inappropriate to be disposed to manipulate people”
“the opinion that people are suitable targets of manipulation will tend to lead to manipulation, which is wrong”
“the ethically relevant belief that people are suitable targets of manipulation is false”
Ahem… Why? To me, these claims seem baseless and to some great degree, false.
I suspect you’re using the word “manipulation” to mean different things.
For that matter, a lot of “manipulation” goes on in Brennan’s world, it’s expected on all sides, they don’t think of themselves as immoral because of it, and I would go ahead and endorse that aspect of their fictional existence. I think that it’s manipulation of someone who isn’t expecting manipulation which is the main ethical problem.
“it’s inappropriate to be disposed to manipulate people” “the opinion that people are suitable targets of manipulation will tend to lead to manipulation, which is wrong” “the ethically relevant belief that people are suitable targets of manipulation is false”
Ahem… Why? To me, these claims seem baseless and to some great degree, false.
It would seem that you and I disagree on matters of ethics, then—probably on an awfully basic level.
I suspect you’re using the word “manipulation” to mean different things.
For that matter, a lot of “manipulation” goes on in Brennan’s world, it’s expected on all sides, they don’t think of themselves as immoral because of it, and I would go ahead and endorse that aspect of their fictional existence. I think that it’s manipulation of someone who isn’t expecting manipulation which is the main ethical problem.