Sure, that patch wouldn’t have the problem I described.
Anyway, do whatever works for you—if you find this exercise helps people train their calibration, then I suppose that’s a good thing. I guess my main point would be not to take too seriously what this method tells us about who is “best” at calibration—and I guess you’re saying people already don’t take seriously in the case of someone who is doing badly at the trivia portion, but I think the failure mode is a bit more general than that. Anyway, I guess it doesn’t matter too much.
Sure, that patch wouldn’t have the problem I described.
Anyway, do whatever works for you—if you find this exercise helps people train their calibration, then I suppose that’s a good thing. I guess my main point would be not to take too seriously what this method tells us about who is “best” at calibration—and I guess you’re saying people already don’t take seriously in the case of someone who is doing badly at the trivia portion, but I think the failure mode is a bit more general than that. Anyway, I guess it doesn’t matter too much.