17 points? That is how much karma CronoDAS has earned from this comment (as of this writing). Don’t get me wrong, it’s a fine comment, but 17 points? Maybe I should be more concerned about good comments with zero points, or stupid comments with two points, but this is one more observation leading me to question karma. If the community deems my comment a distraction, I apologize.
Sorry to pick on you CronoDAS, I’ll go look through your history and vote up some of your under-valued comments.
Or maybe I’m wrong to think 17 points inappropriate, maybe I should think more on why the community judged it so highly. And/or maybe lots more comments should earn this much karma.
Added: LW is inevitably changing. One can see it in the quantity and character of top level posts, and in how posts and comments earn karma. I suggest that someone make a top level post to discuss it.
I think the high rating of the comment is a reflection of the problem that Eliezer’s post was sub-par (especially taking into account that he’s, you know, brilliant). Voting up a (partial) rebuttal, even if it isn’t great on its own terms, is a reasonably polite way to express this.
(But I’m very new here—this is my fourth comment—so maybe I have no idea what the dynamic is.)
17 points? That is how much karma CronoDAS has earned from this comment (as of this writing). Don’t get me wrong, it’s a fine comment, but 17 points? Maybe I should be more concerned about good comments with zero points, or stupid comments with two points, but this is one more observation leading me to question karma. If the community deems my comment a distraction, I apologize.
Sorry to pick on you CronoDAS, I’ll go look through your history and vote up some of your under-valued comments.
Or maybe I’m wrong to think 17 points inappropriate, maybe I should think more on why the community judged it so highly. And/or maybe lots more comments should earn this much karma.
Added: LW is inevitably changing. One can see it in the quantity and character of top level posts, and in how posts and comments earn karma. I suggest that someone make a top level post to discuss it.
I think the high rating of the comment is a reflection of the problem that Eliezer’s post was sub-par (especially taking into account that he’s, you know, brilliant). Voting up a (partial) rebuttal, even if it isn’t great on its own terms, is a reasonably polite way to express this.
(But I’m very new here—this is my fourth comment—so maybe I have no idea what the dynamic is.)
I’m surprised, too...