fwiw my take on the FHE argument in case you find it valuable, although I think i’ve already talked to you about this, but: personally I think it actually applies to every computation because the same way you need to decrypt the FHE you need to “decrypt” the state of every electron/particle involved the computation into its “semantic meaning” (whatever that means). so for the same reason as mentioned in this post, plus the fact that “semantic meaning” is quite ill-defined, I am very distasteful of computationalism
fwiw my take on the FHE argument in case you find it valuable, although I think i’ve already talked to you about this, but: personally I think it actually applies to every computation because the same way you need to decrypt the FHE you need to “decrypt” the state of every electron/particle involved the computation into its “semantic meaning” (whatever that means). so for the same reason as mentioned in this post, plus the fact that “semantic meaning” is quite ill-defined, I am very distasteful of computationalism