Asym­met­ric Weapons

TagLast edit: 8 Mar 2021 15:09 UTC by Yoav Ravid

Asymmetric Weapons are weapons that are inherently more powerful to one side of a conflict than another—Unlike a symmetric weapon, which can used as effectively by both sides. The term was originally introduced by Scott Alexander in his essay Guided By The Beauty Of Our Weapons, where he argued that truth, facts, and logic are asymmetric weapons for “the good guys”:

Logical debate has one advantage over narrative, rhetoric, and violence: it’s an asymmetric weapon. That is, it’s a weapon which is stronger in the hands of the good guys than in the hands of the bad guys. In ideal conditions (which may or may not ever happen in real life) – the kind of conditions where everyone is charitable and intelligent and wise – the good guys will be able to present stronger evidence, cite more experts, and invoke more compelling moral principles. The whole point of logic is that, when done right, it can only prove things that are true.

In the same essay he gave rhetoric and violence as examples of symmetric weapons.

Violence is a symmetric weapon; the bad guys’ punches hit just as hard as the good guys’ do. [...] the same is true of rhetoric. Martin Luther King was able to make persuasive emotional appeals for good things. But Hitler was able to make persuasive emotional appeals for bad things. I’ve previously argued that Mohammed counts as the most successful persuader of all time. These three people pushed three very different ideologies, and rhetoric worked for them all.

Scott uses this terminology mainly to separate strategies that work especially well for “the good guys” and strategies that work equally well for both sides. Davis Kingsley warns that strategies can also be asymmetric in favor of “the bad guys”.

“Unless you use asymmetric weapons, the best you can hope for is to win by coincidence.”—Scott Alexander

External Links

Related Pages: Memetics, Public Discourse

Guided By The Beauty Of Our Weapons

Scott Alexander24 Mar 2017 4:33 UTC
35 points
4 comments19 min readLW link

Asym­met­ric Weapons Aren’t Always on Your Side

Davis_Kingsley8 Jun 2019 8:47 UTC
31 points
20 comments2 min readLW link