I don’t think su3su2su1 made any claim involving donations split by EA-ness; wasn’t it just that the median donation reported in the LW survey[1] (as a whole) was zero? (The underlying assumption presumably being that LW is a Wretched Hive of Scum and Effective Altruism, so that if LW users generally aren’t generous then EAs must likewise not be generous.)
[1] Which LW survey? No idea, of course. It seems fairly clear that su3su2su1 was prioritizing for rhetorical effect over accurate analysis anyway.
I don’t think su3su2su1 made any claim involving donations split by EA-ness; wasn’t it just that the median donation reported in the LW survey[1] (as a whole) was zero? (The underlying assumption presumably being that LW is a Wretched Hive of Scum and Effective Altruism, so that if LW users generally aren’t generous then EAs must likewise not be generous.)
[1] Which LW survey? No idea, of course. It seems fairly clear that su3su2su1 was prioritizing for rhetorical effect over accurate analysis anyway.
Of course he did. It’s literally the first line of my post:
Wow. I totally can’t read. You are of course completely right. Sorry about that.