The argument for (1) and (2) being unstable seems to fail on empirical grounds. Consider the current situation between humans and domesticated chickens. Humans have full control. Presumably, if the chickens have feelings, they are quite unhappy about this. Yet there is nothing they can do to change it. The equilibrium is stable (absent intervention from e.g. chicken-loving humans).
Maybe you mean something different at the beginning of your post, but idk what that might be.
The argument for (1) and (2) being unstable seems to fail on empirical grounds. Consider the current situation between humans and domesticated chickens. Humans have full control. Presumably, if the chickens have feelings, they are quite unhappy about this. Yet there is nothing they can do to change it. The equilibrium is stable (absent intervention from e.g. chicken-loving humans).
Maybe you mean something different at the beginning of your post, but idk what that might be.