Seems to have hit a nerve judging the downvoting rate of −1 karma/hour or so, aye. I’d have expected agreement karma to go down but less so the overall karma as in: not too terrible to think about that question even if the conjecture turns out to be wrong—though everyone’s taste is of course different.
I now explicitly flag the post as what it is meant to be: A thought provocation—meant to explore whether/where a quick thought goes wrong (I thought without saying quick takes are meant for that in particular too).
Seems to have hit a nerve judging the downvoting rate of −1 karma/hour or so, aye. I’d have expected agreement karma to go down but less so the overall karma as in: not too terrible to think about that question even if the conjecture turns out to be wrong—though everyone’s taste is of course different.
I now explicitly flag the post as what it is meant to be: A thought provocation—meant to explore whether/where a quick thought goes wrong (I thought without saying quick takes are meant for that in particular too).