I’m not sure this is responsive to Will’s point… at least, it seems plausible that the moral considerations he considers identity to imperfectly encapsulate are also normative, which is why he refers to them as moral in the first place. That is, I think he means to challenge the idea that identity shouldn’t be/isn’t a normative consideration.
I’m not sure this is responsive to Will’s point… at least, it seems plausible that the moral considerations he considers identity to imperfectly encapsulate are also normative, which is why he refers to them as moral in the first place. That is, I think he means to challenge the idea that identity shouldn’t be/isn’t a normative consideration.