1) Nah, probably not. Some common standards could be nice, but they should be specific, and once we start trying to do something LW-specific rather than some flavor of “general,” karma ain’t broke. Self-assigned standards might work if you can resist or somehow (like with another person) police gaming the system, but there’s already systems for that.
2) The problem is inherent—putting things in this structure requires that you assign them relative worths. There may be an average answer, but average is wrong for a lot of people.
1) Nah, probably not. Some common standards could be nice, but they should be specific, and once we start trying to do something LW-specific rather than some flavor of “general,” karma ain’t broke. Self-assigned standards might work if you can resist or somehow (like with another person) police gaming the system, but there’s already systems for that.
2) The problem is inherent—putting things in this structure requires that you assign them relative worths. There may be an average answer, but average is wrong for a lot of people.