There is one offhand remark, vengeance, and a practical cold-heartedness favoring Bones. “Why not Bones?” is only a little better than no argument at all.
Also there is the fact (mentioned by someone else, sorry I forget who) that Narcissa’s sister, Bellatrix, murdered Bones’ brother. Edit: I am an idiot, you already mentioned this.
Bringing in Aberforth is a really interesting idea. Now that I think about it, even given the wizarding wars, it is remarkable that so many siblings have died or nearly died:
Albus/Aberforth
Bellatrix/Narcissa
Bones/her brother (who, exactly?)
Petunia/Lily
The last one is interesting with the role of survivor exchanged as well, since there is a hint that Petunia may have threatened suicide in order to convince Lily to brew the beauty potion.
Eponymuse, I think I covered that with the word ‘vengeance.’
Those coincidences are otherwise satisfied by the fact that Bones’ motives are served by Narcissa’s Immolation, whoever did it. Given what we know about her, she’d act the same way if Dumbledore or Moody were Narcissa’s Immolator. Still, it does make some narrative sense for her be the one.
I am not at all confident that Aberforth was involved. I would like it very much, though, if someone could add something more to or take something away from the rickety scaffold propping this theory up.
Aberforth may have died just to emphasize the harshness of the war in ways the source did not. If that’s the case, I’m making a red herring out of a pointless bit of the set. However, there was nothing in the text that tells us that Aberforth was a tragic casualty of a meaningless war or anything of the sort. For now he looks, to me, like a gun on the mantle.
Also, I guess “siblings getting killed” isn’t much of a pattern. Given that people were getting killed in the war, and that people have siblings, you can count the people getting killed as siblings.
“That depends,” Amelia said in a hard voice. “Are you here to help us catch criminals, or to protect them from the consequences of their actions?” Are you going to try to stop the killer of my brother from getting her well-deserved Kiss, old meddler?
Also there is the fact (mentioned by someone else, sorry I forget who) that Narcissa’s sister, Bellatrix, murdered Bones’ brother. Edit: I am an idiot, you already mentioned this.
Bringing in Aberforth is a really interesting idea. Now that I think about it, even given the wizarding wars, it is remarkable that so many siblings have died or nearly died:
Albus/Aberforth
Bellatrix/Narcissa
Bones/her brother (who, exactly?)
Petunia/Lily
The last one is interesting with the role of survivor exchanged as well, since there is a hint that Petunia may have threatened suicide in order to convince Lily to brew the beauty potion.
Also, Bones is the one who speaks up to stop Dumbledore from “confessing” to killing Narcissa.
I think it’s Bones. Too many coincidences otherwise.
Eponymuse, I think I covered that with the word ‘vengeance.’
Those coincidences are otherwise satisfied by the fact that Bones’ motives are served by Narcissa’s Immolation, whoever did it. Given what we know about her, she’d act the same way if Dumbledore or Moody were Narcissa’s Immolator. Still, it does make some narrative sense for her be the one.
I am not at all confident that Aberforth was involved. I would like it very much, though, if someone could add something more to or take something away from the rickety scaffold propping this theory up.
Aberforth may have died just to emphasize the harshness of the war in ways the source did not. If that’s the case, I’m making a red herring out of a pointless bit of the set. However, there was nothing in the text that tells us that Aberforth was a tragic casualty of a meaningless war or anything of the sort. For now he looks, to me, like a gun on the mantle.
Sorry, apparently I’m illiterate.
Also, I guess “siblings getting killed” isn’t much of a pattern. Given that people were getting killed in the war, and that people have siblings, you can count the people getting killed as siblings.
It was meee. Also there’s the Bellatrix idea.
/shameless self-promotion
No, it’s Amelia herself in Chapter 56.
I don’t get it. Why did you quote my first link?