Honest dilemma: Should Hermione decide to get the memories of casting the Blood-chilling Charm obliviated?
On one hand, one would think that messing even more with Hermione’s mind should be a no-no. On the other hand, we’re pretty sure it’s a false memory, and it seems grossly unfair for her to have to remember attempting to commit a murder that she didn’t truly attempt.
Second question: Regardless of what Hermione should do, will she so decide it?
Third question: If she doesn’t so decide, will some helpful other person override said choice for her sake and obliviate her anyway?
If she does get the memory erased, she’s going to be awfully confused when someone else inevitably brings it up again.
Edit: it occurs to me that you probably only meant the memory of performing the charm itself, not the memory of being put on trial for murder. But even if they did that, I suspect she’d imagine something just as bad to fill the space, knowing what was supposed to go in it.
Honest dilemma: Should Hermione decide to get the memories of casting the Blood-chilling Charm obliviated?
On one hand, one would think that messing even more with Hermione’s mind should be a no-no. On the other hand, we’re pretty sure it’s a false memory, and it seems grossly unfair for her to have to remember attempting to commit a murder that she didn’t truly attempt.
Second question: Regardless of what Hermione should do, will she so decide it?
Third question: If she doesn’t so decide, will some helpful other person override said choice for her sake and obliviate her anyway?
If she does get the memory erased, she’s going to be awfully confused when someone else inevitably brings it up again.
Edit: it occurs to me that you probably only meant the memory of performing the charm itself, not the memory of being put on trial for murder. But even if they did that, I suspect she’d imagine something just as bad to fill the space, knowing what was supposed to go in it.
If she wanted to do that, I’d have the memory extracted and saved as evidence.