You are making excuses for your assumptions by piling on more assumptions. Chapter 6 is written in a way that does not make the speaker clear. That looks deliberate. We are given Harry’s opinion of who said it, but he never confirms that with McGonagall. We’ve been in McGonagall’s head quite a few times, and she has never thought back to playing match-maker.
You may believe that was McGonagall. You may be right. But when you say, “we already know,” you are mistaken.
You are making excuses for your assumptions by piling on more assumptions.
You’re misusing the word assumption. I don’t *assume” that was McGonaggal’s reason, I simply judged it to be the most likely and most natural explanation, given the facts in evidence. But yes, I did assume that my initial reading of the text and that Harry also wasn’t being mistaken about who told him about Hermione. As I said, I didn’t even realize some people saw this bit as a mystery. That’s what true assumptions look like, I guess, when one doesn’t even realize some people consider it a question.
You may believe that was McGonagall. You may be right. But when you say, “we already know,” you are mistaken.
Okay. As I said, when I wrote that sentence, i didn’t even realize there existed people who considered this a question. Discussing more about this would probably just be about what the word “knowledge” means.
You are making excuses for your assumptions by piling on more assumptions. Chapter 6 is written in a way that does not make the speaker clear. That looks deliberate. We are given Harry’s opinion of who said it, but he never confirms that with McGonagall. We’ve been in McGonagall’s head quite a few times, and she has never thought back to playing match-maker.
You may believe that was McGonagall. You may be right. But when you say, “we already know,” you are mistaken.
You’re misusing the word assumption. I don’t *assume” that was McGonaggal’s reason, I simply judged it to be the most likely and most natural explanation, given the facts in evidence. But yes, I did assume that my initial reading of the text and that Harry also wasn’t being mistaken about who told him about Hermione. As I said, I didn’t even realize some people saw this bit as a mystery. That’s what true assumptions look like, I guess, when one doesn’t even realize some people consider it a question.
Okay. As I said, when I wrote that sentence, i didn’t even realize there existed people who considered this a question. Discussing more about this would probably just be about what the word “knowledge” means.