This shows why it DOES matter: Both Collatz and p² = 2q² require going above arithmetic to even state them (“for ALL numbers...”). That’s the key insight—we can’t even formulate these interesting conjectures within pure arithmetic, let alone prove them. In pure arithmetic we can only check specific cases:
This shows why it DOES matter: Both Collatz and p² = 2q² require going above arithmetic to even state them (“for ALL numbers...”). That’s the key insight—we can’t even formulate these interesting conjectures within pure arithmetic, let alone prove them. In pure arithmetic we can only check specific cases:
“4 goes to 2”
“3² ≠ 2×2²”