The boundaries between present-day people and non-people can be sharper, by a fiat of many intervening class members being nonexistent, than the ideal categories.
Fair point.
More to the point, a CEV-based AI has a potentially different definition of ‘sentient being’ and ‘the class I am to extrapolate’. Theoretically you could be given the latter definition by pointing
Mm. Theoretically, yes, I suppose someone could point to every person, and I could be constructed so as to not generalize the extrapolated class beyond the particular targets I’ve been given.
I’m not sure I would endorse that, but I think that gets us into questions of what the extrapolated class ought to comprise in the first place, which is a much larger and mostly tangential discussion.
Fair point.
Mm. Theoretically, yes, I suppose someone could point to every person, and I could be constructed so as to not generalize the extrapolated class beyond the particular targets I’ve been given.
I’m not sure I would endorse that, but I think that gets us into questions of what the extrapolated class ought to comprise in the first place, which is a much larger and mostly tangential discussion.
So, fair enough… point taken.