Believeing in materialism does not reduce subjectviity, and neither does believing in the reducibility of subjectivity.
I have no idea what this means. Believing or disbelieving in things generally doesn’t poof them in or out of existence, but seeing as neither of us here are omniscient, I’m not sure why you’d bring it up.
Do you believe that subjective experiences are “irreducible” ? If so, you are making a very strong existential claim, and you need to provide more evidence than you’ve done so far.
That kind of depends on what the question is, and you still haven’t told me. If the question is, “who makes the most delicious cupcakes”, then Materialism is probably not the answer. If the question is, “how do you account for the irreducibility of subjective experience”, then Materialism is not the answer either, since you have not convinced me that subjective experience is irreducible, and thus the answer is “mu”.
I haven’t told you because they haven’t told me. Which is not surprising, since thinking about what the questions are tends to reveal that materaiism doens’t answer most of them.
Ok, so there are some questions that materialism doesn’t answer, but you don’t know what those questions are, or why it doesn’t answer them ? Why are we still talking about this, then ?
I know what the questions materialism doesn’t answer are. I’ve mentioned them repeatedly. I don’t know what the questions materialism does answer are, ebcause the true Believers wont say.
I have no idea what this means. Believing or disbelieving in things generally doesn’t poof them in or out of existence, but seeing as neither of us here are omniscient, I’m not sure why you’d bring it up.
Do you believe that subjective experiences are “irreducible” ? If so, you are making a very strong existential claim, and you need to provide more evidence than you’ve done so far.
People keep telling me that Accpeting Materialism is The Answer. You don’t beleive that, don’t. But people keep tellig me.
That kind of depends on what the question is, and you still haven’t told me. If the question is, “who makes the most delicious cupcakes”, then Materialism is probably not the answer. If the question is, “how do you account for the irreducibility of subjective experience”, then Materialism is not the answer either, since you have not convinced me that subjective experience is irreducible, and thus the answer is “mu”.
I haven’t told you because they haven’t told me. Which is not surprising, since thinking about what the questions are tends to reveal that materaiism doens’t answer most of them.
Ok, so there are some questions that materialism doesn’t answer, but you don’t know what those questions are, or why it doesn’t answer them ? Why are we still talking about this, then ?
I know what the questions materialism doesn’t answer are. I’ve mentioned them repeatedly. I don’t know what the questions materialism does answer are, ebcause the true Believers wont say.