(b) it sounds like I’m willing to classify more things as “death” than you are.
I don’t think this matters much. I’m happy to consider non-consensual uploading to be death and I’m certainly happy to consider “the humans are modified in some way they would find horrifying (at least on reflection)” to be death. I think “the humans are alive in the normal sense of alive” is totally plausible and I expect some humans to be alive in the normal sense of alive in the majority of worlds where AIs takeover.
Making uploads is barely cheaper than literally keeping physical humans alive after AIs have fully solidified their power I think, maybe 0-3 OOMs more expensive or something, so I don’t think non-consensual uploads are that much of the action. (I do think rounding humans up into shelters is relevant.)
I don’t think this matters much. I’m happy to consider non-consensual uploading to be death and I’m certainly happy to consider “the humans are modified in some way they would find horrifying (at least on reflection)” to be death. I think “the humans are alive in the normal sense of alive” is totally plausible and I expect some humans to be alive in the normal sense of alive in the majority of worlds where AIs takeover.
Making uploads is barely cheaper than literally keeping physical humans alive after AIs have fully solidified their power I think, maybe 0-3 OOMs more expensive or something, so I don’t think non-consensual uploads are that much of the action. (I do think rounding humans up into shelters is relevant.)