I know many people whose lives were radically changed by The Lord of the Rings, The Narnia Chronicles, Star Wars, or Ender’s Game.
The first three spawned a vast juvenile fantasy genre which convinces people that they’re in a war between pure good and pure evil, in which the moral thing to do is always blindingly obvious. (Star Wars at least had a redemption arc, and didn’t divide good and evil along racial lines. In LotR and Narnia, as in Marxism and Nazism, the only possible solution is to kill or expel every member of the evil races/classes.) I know people on both sides of today’s culture war who I believe were radicalized by Lord of the Rings.
Today’s readers don’t even know fantasy wasn’t that way before Tolkien and Lewis! It was adult literature, not wish-fulfilment. Read Gormenghast,A Voyage to Arcturus,The Worm Ouroboros, or The King of Elfland’s Daughter. It often had a nihilistic or tragic worldview, but never the pablum of Lewis or Tolkien.
Ender’s Game convinces people that they are super-geniuses who can turn the course of history single-handedly. Usually this turns out badly, though it seems to have worked for Eliezer.
I know many people whose lives were radically changed by The Lord of the Rings, The Narnia Chronicles, Star Wars, or Ender’s Game.
The first three spawned a vast juvenile fantasy genre which convinces people that they’re in a war between pure good and pure evil, in which the moral thing to do is always blindingly obvious. (Star Wars at least had a redemption arc, and didn’t divide good and evil along racial lines. In LotR and Narnia, as in Marxism and Nazism, the only possible solution is to kill or expel every member of the evil races/classes.) I know people on both sides of today’s culture war who I believe were radicalized by Lord of the Rings.
Today’s readers don’t even know fantasy wasn’t that way before Tolkien and Lewis! It was adult literature, not wish-fulfilment. Read Gormenghast, A Voyage to Arcturus, The Worm Ouroboros, or The King of Elfland’s Daughter. It often had a nihilistic or tragic worldview, but never the pablum of Lewis or Tolkien.
Ender’s Game convinces people that they are super-geniuses who can turn the course of history single-handedly. Usually this turns out badly, though it seems to have worked for Eliezer.