yeah I think we should allow christian homeschools to exist in the year 3000.
But this cuts against some other moral intuitions, like “people shouldn’t be made worse off as a means to an end” (e.g. I don’t think we should have wars as a means to inspire poets). And presumably the people in the christian homeschools are worse off.
Maybe the compromise is something like:
On every day you are in the homeschool, we will “uplift” you if we think you would “ideally” want that.
Something like pre-existence theodicy, i.e. people born to Christian homeschooling parents consent to that life before they are incarnate, possibly in return for compensation (supposing something like souls or personal identity exists).
I’m hopeful the details can be fleshed out in late crunch-time.
I’m hopeful the details can be fleshed out in late crunch-time.
You don’t want to be figuring out ethics in crunch time, you want to be figuring out how to pass off (or buy time to pass off) the question to something-like-CEV or a long reflection.
yeah I think we should allow christian homeschools to exist in the year 3000.
But this cuts against some other moral intuitions, like “people shouldn’t be made worse off as a means to an end” (e.g. I don’t think we should have wars as a means to inspire poets). And presumably the people in the christian homeschools are worse off.
Maybe the compromise is something like:
On every day you are in the homeschool, we will “uplift” you if we think you would “ideally” want that.
Something like pre-existence theodicy, i.e. people born to Christian homeschooling parents consent to that life before they are incarnate, possibly in return for compensation (supposing something like souls or personal identity exists).
I’m hopeful the details can be fleshed out in late crunch-time.
You don’t want to be figuring out ethics in crunch time, you want to be figuring out how to pass off (or buy time to pass off) the question to something-like-CEV or a long reflection.