Is it an attainable counterfactual, though? The only positive counterexamples you presented were a centuries-old Ottoman practice, and the aftermath of the worst war ever. These days, though, it doesn’t seem like anybody anywhere in the world does meritocracy better than the US, however faint a praise this might be, so clearly the problem is far from trivial.
China’s track record suggests a more recent positive trajectory, so that their measured quality of life seems on par with the US despite the US’s vastly superior per capita endowment as recently as 1980, and their industrial and technological capacity is not unambiguously inferior.
Well, I do agree that either an especially benign new religious movement or an especially benign communist dictatorship might be the way forward, but that still leaves more questions than answers.
Is it an attainable counterfactual, though? The only positive counterexamples you presented were a centuries-old Ottoman practice, and the aftermath of the worst war ever. These days, though, it doesn’t seem like anybody anywhere in the world does meritocracy better than the US, however faint a praise this might be, so clearly the problem is far from trivial.
Calvinist England is a well documented culturally near case.
China’s track record suggests a more recent positive trajectory, so that their measured quality of life seems on par with the US despite the US’s vastly superior per capita endowment as recently as 1980, and their industrial and technological capacity is not unambiguously inferior.
Well, I do agree that either an especially benign new religious movement or an especially benign communist dictatorship might be the way forward, but that still leaves more questions than answers.