I would ask Lucy if she would still eat the cake if the sugar industry were doing fine. More generally, I would ask if there is any action Lucy is taking that they would not take if the sugar industry were doing fine.
Ask the participants to come up with a belief that they feel is important to them but hasn’t been necessary (though they may mistakenly think it sufficient) for making any meaningful decisions.
I would ask Lucy if she would still eat the cake if the sugar industry were doing fine. More generally, I would ask if there is any action Lucy is taking that they would not take if the sugar industry were doing fine.
Ask the participants to come up with a belief that they feel is important to them but hasn’t been necessary (though they may mistakenly think it sufficient) for making any meaningful decisions.
Perhaps Lucy would do well do ask:
What if eating the cake somehow harmed the sugar industry? How would I feel about that?