I don’t think the title is correct. Based on your anecdote and those in the comments thus far, the kind of irritation you’re talking about probably isn’t a result of being exposed to too many rational memes, it’s more likely a result of some kind of social signalling effect or repeated exposure to particular rational memes. I don’t have a particularly good title in mind, but something like “Irritation at Irrational Beliefs” removes the inaccuracy.
If I add ‘social signalling effects’ as a subtitle, does that make it more clear? I don’t think ‘Irritation at Irrational Beliefs’ explains it as well because I have always spent time around people with ‘irrational’ beliefs, and never been bothered by it until I also spent a lot of time on LW.
I agree that my proposed title is lame and unhelpful, but I don’t think “too many rational memes” is the root cause of this phenomenon. It seems unlikely that there is some threshold number of rationality-themed memes such that people start instinctively hating religion once they have been exposed to enough of them.
Personally, I would call what I think Swimmer963 is talking about the problem of outgroup contempt. But I also don’t much care what the title of the post is.
I don’t think the title is correct. Based on your anecdote and those in the comments thus far, the kind of irritation you’re talking about probably isn’t a result of being exposed to too many rational memes, it’s more likely a result of some kind of social signalling effect or repeated exposure to particular rational memes. I don’t have a particularly good title in mind, but something like “Irritation at Irrational Beliefs” removes the inaccuracy.
If I add ‘social signalling effects’ as a subtitle, does that make it more clear? I don’t think ‘Irritation at Irrational Beliefs’ explains it as well because I have always spent time around people with ‘irrational’ beliefs, and never been bothered by it until I also spent a lot of time on LW.
I agree that my proposed title is lame and unhelpful, but I don’t think “too many rational memes” is the root cause of this phenomenon. It seems unlikely that there is some threshold number of rationality-themed memes such that people start instinctively hating religion once they have been exposed to enough of them.
Personally, I would call what I think Swimmer963 is talking about the problem of outgroup contempt. But I also don’t much care what the title of the post is.