I don’t think you claim has support as presented. Part of the problem surrounding the question is that we still don’t really have any way of measuring how “conscious” something is. In order to claim that something is or isn’t conscious, you should have some working definition of what conscious means, and how it can be measured. If you want to have a serious discussion instead of competing emotional positions, you need to support the claim with points that can be confirmed or denied. Why doesn’t a goldfish have consciousness, or an earthworm? How can you know? You can borrow concepts from some theoretical concepts like Integrated Information Theory or Non-Trivial Information Closure etc. but you should make some effort to ground the claim.
As for my opinion, whatever your definition of consciousness is I think a digital entity can in principle be conscious since I think consciousness is closely related to certain types of information, but beyond that without a more rigorous perspective I think the conversation isn’t going anywhere fruitful.
I don’t think you claim has support as presented. Part of the problem surrounding the question is that we still don’t really have any way of measuring how “conscious” something is. In order to claim that something is or isn’t conscious, you should have some working definition of what conscious means, and how it can be measured. If you want to have a serious discussion instead of competing emotional positions, you need to support the claim with points that can be confirmed or denied. Why doesn’t a goldfish have consciousness, or an earthworm? How can you know? You can borrow concepts from some theoretical concepts like Integrated Information Theory or Non-Trivial Information Closure etc. but you should make some effort to ground the claim.
As for my opinion, whatever your definition of consciousness is I think a digital entity can in principle be conscious since I think consciousness is closely related to certain types of information, but beyond that without a more rigorous perspective I think the conversation isn’t going anywhere fruitful.