The Trickle-Down Effect of Good Communities

We don’t know who came up with the ancient Indian idea of karma or why they did so, but one of its social functions is to motivate people to behave better. If people really believe that they will suffer for their evil actions and prosper for their good actions due to a law of nature, this probably motivates them to do more good and less evil.

Less Wrong, of course, has a karma system. You gain karma points if you write something that people value, and you lose karma points if you write something that people think is inappropriate. At low levels, gaining karma points gives you new posting privileges. At high levels, karma points indicate something like your status in the community.

Recently I noticed that I post better comments on Less Wrong than I usually do on my own site. I think this is partly due to Less Wrong’s karma system. When I draft a comment or a post for Less Wrong, I’m more likely to (1) talk to others charitably and with respect and (2) go out of my way to provide useful links and context than I when I draft a comment for my own site!

And now I find myself motivated to bring a stronger emphasis on those qualities to the writing on my own site. So the Less Wrong karma system is having a trickle-down effect into other areas of my life.

Which got me thinking… it might be helpful to have a karma system in “real life,” beyond the pages of Less Wrong (or reddit). Maybe something like Facebook karma. People could anonymously add and subtract points on people’s Facebook profiles according to whether or not that person acted like a douche in daily life. This could be done by a smartphone app, and plugged into Facebook via an opt-in Facebook app that users could voluntarily choose to add to their profiles.