In dath ilan, inflation and deflation are not used as macroeconomic tools because people are rational enough to accept wage reductions if their purchasing power remains unchanged, or to voluntarily pay the government to prevent crises without the need for a hidden tax that dilutes money by printing more during a crisis. Interest rates on loans could be lower if you expect returns that outpace deflation. If people can afford not to work, they are expected to do so, and they would spend more “shares”, redistributing them in favor of those who are more eager to work. Perhaps you aren’t really interested in having people work that much or that often, especially if you’re aiming for a utopia with a four-hour workday, or something similar. How relevant are these issues in a world where “every person is economist in the same way every earthling is a scribe by medieval standards”?
To be fair, before publishing I thought this currency could be implemented in a real world environment with less improbability. My current main doubt is “how can the market cap be so volatile with a stable GDP, and would they be closer to each other in a more adequate equilibrium?”. And I’ve basically switched to “okay oops, but under what conditions could this theoretically work, if could at all, and could you imagine better theoretical peak conditions?” mode. Deflation seems like a reasonable danger, I just can’t see how it could be avoided if everyone used market fractions at least to store their money if not to exchange. Because, like, you don’t introduce a random money-making machine into the system to solve your psychological problems at the cost of 2% of your money, there’s no place for it, so I’m guessing that people would adapt to that, and there’s a fictional example of dath ilan that such adaptation is real.
In dath ilan, inflation and deflation are not used as macroeconomic tools because people are rational enough to accept wage reductions if their purchasing power remains unchanged, or to voluntarily pay the government to prevent crises without the need for a hidden tax that dilutes money by printing more during a crisis. Interest rates on loans could be lower if you expect returns that outpace deflation. If people can afford not to work, they are expected to do so, and they would spend more “shares”, redistributing them in favor of those who are more eager to work. Perhaps you aren’t really interested in having people work that much or that often, especially if you’re aiming for a utopia with a four-hour workday, or something similar. How relevant are these issues in a world where “every person is economist in the same way every earthling is a scribe by medieval standards”?
Ok fair. I was assuming real world conditions rather than the ideal of Dath Ilan. Sorry for the confusion.
To be fair, before publishing I thought this currency could be implemented in a real world environment with less improbability. My current main doubt is “how can the market cap be so volatile with a stable GDP, and would they be closer to each other in a more adequate equilibrium?”. And I’ve basically switched to “okay oops, but under what conditions could this theoretically work, if could at all, and could you imagine better theoretical peak conditions?” mode. Deflation seems like a reasonable danger, I just can’t see how it could be avoided if everyone used market fractions at least to store their money if not to exchange. Because, like, you don’t introduce a random money-making machine into the system to solve your psychological problems at the cost of 2% of your money, there’s no place for it, so I’m guessing that people would adapt to that, and there’s a fictional example of dath ilan that such adaptation is real.