Now, suppose I have a strong preference to live in a universe where innocent people are never tortured for no good reason. Now, suppose someone in some far-off place that I can never interact with tortures an innocent person for no good reason. Haven’t my preferences been thwarted in some sense?
How do you know it is not happening right now? Since there is no way to tell, by your assumption, you might as well assume the worst and be perpetually unhappy. I warmly recommend instrumentalism as a workable alternative.
There is no need to be unhappy over situations I can’t control. I know that awful things are happening in other countries that I have no control over, but I don’t let that make me unhappy, even though my preferences are being perpetually thwarted by those things happening. But the fact that it doesn’t make me unhappy doesn’t change the fact that it’s not what I’d prefer.
How do you know it is not happening right now? Since there is no way to tell, by your assumption, you might as well assume the worst and be perpetually unhappy. I warmly recommend instrumentalism as a workable alternative.
There is no need to be unhappy over situations I can’t control. I know that awful things are happening in other countries that I have no control over, but I don’t let that make me unhappy, even though my preferences are being perpetually thwarted by those things happening. But the fact that it doesn’t make me unhappy doesn’t change the fact that it’s not what I’d prefer.