asr comments on Scott Aaronson’s lecture on free will

[asr]

My definition picks out a set of things I want to talk about, and captures what I mean when I use the term free will. If you don’t like that definition, what’s yours?

I assume you want to define free will in an incompatiblist way. If so, I ask what understanding that definition aids or what explanatory power it has?

[RobertLumley]

I gave a definition in my opening comment:

To me, the question of free will is the question of a deterministic universe.

To quote you, my definition picks out a set of things I want to talk about, and captures what I mean when I use the term free will.

If you want to define free will that way, that’s fine. But it doesn’t help answer the question of do you actually have it.