I think it’s a bit sad that this comment is being so well-received—it’s just some opinions without arguments from someone who hasn’t read the paper in detail.
I disagree—I think Ryan raised an obvious objection that we didn’t directly address in the paper. I’d like to encourage medium-effort engagement from people as paged-in as Ryan. The discussion spawned was valuable to me.
I think it’s a bit sad that this comment is being so well-received—it’s just some opinions without arguments from someone who hasn’t read the paper in detail.
I disagree—I think Ryan raised an obvious objection that we didn’t directly address in the paper. I’d like to encourage medium-effort engagement from people as paged-in as Ryan. The discussion spawned was valuable to me.
Agreed, downvoted my comment. (You can’t strong downvote your own comment, or I would have done that.)
I was mostly just trying to point to prior arguments against similar arguments while expressing my view.