One thing that jumps out at me is that Total Research Transparency is to some extent the opposite of cybersecurity hardening to prevent hacking. The fact that there are plausible arguments for both suggests to me that we have a lot of uncertainty about what policies we should be pursuing. And this in turn would seem to suggest that we should favour corrigible plans that can be amended later, which seems like an argument against Total Research Transparency: once we have enacted it, we can no longer put that particular genie back in the bottle.
Thanks for sharing, very interesting.
One thing that jumps out at me is that Total Research Transparency is to some extent the opposite of cybersecurity hardening to prevent hacking. The fact that there are plausible arguments for both suggests to me that we have a lot of uncertainty about what policies we should be pursuing. And this in turn would seem to suggest that we should favour corrigible plans that can be amended later, which seems like an argument against Total Research Transparency: once we have enacted it, we can no longer put that particular genie back in the bottle.