Buck’s reply seems reasonable and I feel pretty good about it!
I do wish your first comment were more like this one (although obviously demanding that every critique were contextualized so thoroughly would be ridiculous), but I’m grateful that you unpacked this here. Thanks!
Edit: I also don’t have any evidence that contradicts your account of your own behavior, to be clear.
Buck’s reply seems reasonable and I feel pretty good about it!
I do wish your first comment were more like this one (although obviously demanding that every critique were contextualized so thoroughly would be ridiculous), but I’m grateful that you unpacked this here. Thanks!
Edit: I also don’t have any evidence that contradicts your account of your own behavior, to be clear.